A R T I C L E I N F O | A B S T R A C T | |
ORIGINAL ARTICLE |
Background: Bangladesh has one of South Asia’s highest rates of child marriage, making female adolescents vulnerable to reproductive health risks. Shornokishoree (SK) Network has been implementing a mobilization program in Bangladesh using a variety of community engagement approaches. The main objective is to raise awareness among adolescents in secondary schools, bringing together as many stakeholders as possible. This paper aims to examine the effectiveness of the Network’s interventions and to determine changes in adolescents’ knowledge, attitudes and practices to prevent child marriage.
Methods: 630 participants were recruited from 35 secondary schools across eight divisions of Bangladesh. This study adopted a quasi-experimental design and consisted of a sample for intervention (308) and control group (322). The intervention group consisted of the participants who attended awareness sessions regarding early marriage and reproductive health issues. The study was conducted using stratified random sampling technique. Data were collected through a structured questionnaire and analyzed using SPSS version 23. Chi-square and z-tests were performed to assess the program’s effectiveness including associated factors. Results: The study shows that knowledge about child marriage remained significantly lower (p < 0.01) for the control group compared to the intervention group. Nearly one-third (27.9%) of the experimental group rejected the assumption that women’s marriageability begins with puberty. 38.4% of the participants in the control group were unaware of the consequences of adolescent pregnancy compared to 8.1% of the intervention group (p < 0.01). Additionally, 29.9% of the control group had a very limited understanding of the child mortality and maternal death issues compared to 6.8% of the intervention group (p < 0.01).
Conclusion: The study concluded that the awareness program has been very useful in improving knowledge about child marriage among adolescents, creating an impact on child marriage prevention. Keywords: Child Marriage, Community based participatory research, Adolescent, Bangladesh.
|
|
Article History:
Received: 21 Jan 2023 Revised: 25 Apr 2023 Accepted: 29 Apr 2023 |
||
*Corresponding Author:
Farzana Rashid Brownia Email: browniacbs@gmail.com Tel: +088 1713036844 |
||
Citation: Rashid Brownia F, Habib ShE. Community Mobilization Intervention in Adolescent Early Marriage Awareness in Bangladesh: The Case of Shornokishoree Network. Journal of Social Behavior and Community Health (JSBCH). 2023; 7(1): 1018-1032.
|
1) To determine whether SK Network interventions directed to adolescents in high schools were effective in improving knowledge about child marriage; and
2) To measure the efficiency of the Network’s intervention in changing attitudes and practices about child marriage.
SK as a framework for community mobilization
SK Network is the first of its type in Bangladesh and is considered the inspiration behind high-school-based teenagers. Its goals are to avoid early marriage and disseminate information about concerns pertaining to adolescents' reproductive health. The conceptual framework of the SK Network draws on the model of American psychologist Urie Bronfenbrenner which places power relations at the center of social structure and projects support action at multiple levels — policies, individuals, families, and communities (Bronfenbrenner, 1979; Brown, 2015; Svanemyr et al., 2015). His model was developed as a way of recognizing that an individual is influenced and is affected by a complex range of social impacts and nested environmental interactions. From this epistemological perspective, community mobilization is a participatory and holistic process wherein groups target the wider social and institutional systems that undermine collective efforts to prevent early marriage rather than a way of changing societal norms (Mannell and Dadswell, 2017). To inform its community mobilization program, SK Network created a five-level model of the factors affecting early marriage and the related health issues grounded in the social-ecological model (Islam & Brownia, 2013). An effort to prevent or delay child marriage might include a range of activities that work at the five levels of interest: individual, interpersonal relationships, community, organization, and policy.
The SK Network is an adolescent development program in Bangladesh implemented in 2012. The vision of this program is to create awareness among youths about the harmful practice of child marriage and empower them to know about their sexual and reproductive health rights issues. The initiative of the Network currently exists in all the divisions of Bangladesh. This program operates through secondary school-based clubs, namely SKClubs. Adolescent boys and girls of 6th to 10th grade (aged 11 to 19 years) join this club. Each secondary school has one SK Club including 30 boys and girls. Among them, 2 boys and/or girls are leaders of the club and the remaining 28 boys and/or girls are club members. This club has a designated guide teacher; in most cases, one of the schoolteachers guides the club. The SK leaders operate the clubs in the educational system and act as liaisons with the network group. The club members participate in discussions where they share their knowledge and opinions on a range of subjects related to early marriage and reproductive health during the group sessions, which is supervised by a guide teacher.
Methods
study design
The study used a quasi-experimental design to assess the impact of SK intervention on early marriage prevention outcomes. The design was used to determine the effectiveness of the awareness program amongst high-school-based students in the selected areas. Students were selected from schools where they had benefitted from an awareness program (intervention group), and then, compared with students who did not receive any interventions at their schools (control group). Outcome variables were created based on knowledge, attitudes, and practices related to early marriage.
Study population and setting
The study population included adolescent boys and girls (aged 11 to 19) who were members of the SK Network or SK club studying at the secondary school level (Year 6 to 10). Adolescent boys and girls with similar age cohort studying at secondary schools regarding Control group were selected as the ‘control group’.
SamplingA structured and standardized self-administered questionnaire was developed based on WHO guidelines that generated more relevant and in-depth knowledge from the participants. The tool was translated from English to Bengali and administered to participants who gave informed consent. The questionnaire was divided into four sections comprising 44 questions, and enquired about participants’ socio-demographic characteristics, early marriage’s knowledge, attitude, and practices including their negative consequences. Socio-demographic factors included the level of education, marital status, parents’ education, and types of residence. Knowledge, attitude, and practice (KAP) variables included knowledge about the legal age of marriage, negative consequences of early marriage, problems of early pregnancy, drop-out, knowledge about the incidence of child marriage in their locality, and sources of information. Other measures consisted of attitude with a range of questions measuring mainly ordinal data using a scale. Answers were yes/no/unsure, and strongly disagree/disagree/ slightly disagree/slightly agree/agree/strongly agree (scoring from 1 to 6). The students’ voluntary participation and anonymity were emphasized by teachers and SK club members and through handing out the questionnaires in the schools. The overall response rate was 98%.
Data analysis
Data analysis was performed using SPSS for Windows (version 23). The normality of the continuous variables was verified using Skewness and Kurtosis statistics. Cross-tabulations were performed to summarize the characteristics of the sample and to provide basic information about the variables. Results were presented in numbers and percentages, and Chi-Square tests were performed to compare two categorical variables (control vs. intervention group), as a part of diagnostic analysis. The two-sample z-test was performed to validate whether there was a significant difference between the intervention and Control groups on categorical attributes of knowledge, perception, and attitude. P-value was set at less than or equal to 5% (p ≤ 0.05).
Reliability of data collection instrument
A pretest with different student groups but similar characteristics was used to determine the reliability of data collection instrument. In two secondary schools of Dhaka division, a pretest was conducted. The measures were deemed appropriate for use in the current study since they produced a correlation coefficient (r) of 0.70.
Ethical considerations
Ethical approval was obtained from the Centre for Higher Studies and Research (CHSR) at Bangladesh University of Professionals (Ref. No. LM 23.01.902.858.24.786.25, Date 09 March 2022). The participants were informed about the purpose and objectives of the study. Participants’ consent was obtained prior to data collection, and subsequently, they were given the opportunity to withdraw from the survey at any time. They were well informed that the data collected were only to be used for research purposes. Personal identifications, names, and other sensitive information provided by the participants during the study were handled with confidentiality and anonymity.
Results
Socio-demographic characteristics
Table 1 presents the demographic characteristics of the respondents. The sample consisted of 630 secondary school students. 48.9% (n = 308) of them belonged to the intervention group (schools with a SK club), while 51.1% (n = 321) included in the control group (schools that do not have a club). The distribution of respondents between the intervention and control groups was almost equal (67.9% vs. 67.4%). The majority were female participants (67.7%). The age of the respondents ranged from 10 to 19 with a mean of 14.59 ( ± 2.49). The majority of participants in both the intervention (58.8%) and control groups (53.7%) were within the range of 14 to 17. Full details of the proportions in each of the response categories are given in Table 1.
Table 1. Socio-demographic characteristics of the respondents by intervention and control groups | |||||||
Variables | Intervention (SK) |
Control (non-SK) |
χ2 | P-value | |||
N = 308 | (%) | N = 322 | (%) | ||||
Age 10-13 14-17 18+ |
96 181 31 |
31.2 58.8 10.1 |
113 173 36 |
35.1 53.7 11.2 |
1.62 |
.443 |
|
Gender Male Female |
99 209 |
32.1 67.9 |
105 217 |
32.6 67.4 |
.901 | .015 | |
Father's education No education. Primary Secondary - higher |
31 36 241 |
10.06 11.69 78.25 |
103 64 155 |
31.99 19.88 48.14 |
64.92 | < 0.01 | |
Mother's education No education Primary Secondary or higher |
32 47 229 |
10.39 15.26 74.85 |
111 69 142 |
34.47 21.43 44.10 |
67.93 | < 0.01 |
|
Father’s occupation Agriculture Business Job holders Others |
10 134 121 43 |
3.2 43.5 39.29 13.96 |
40 116 73 93 |
12.4 36.0 30.79 28.88 |
49.26 |
< 0.01 |
|
Mother’s occupation Agriculture Jobholder Housewife |
2 57 249 |
0.65 18.51 80.84 |
37 31 254 |
11.49 9.63 78.88 |
38.84 | < 0.01 | |
Religion Islam Others |
265 43 |
86.04 13.96 |
261 61 |
81.06 18.94 |
28.36 |
0.092 |
|
Level of education Grade 6 Grade 7 Grade 8 Grade 9 Grade 10 |
27 30 57 69 125 |
8.8 9.7 18.5 22.4 40.6 |
40 51 50 99 82 |
12.4 15.8 15.5 30.7 25.5 |
22.41 | < 0.01 | |
Use of smartphone Yes No |
165 143 |
53.6 46.4 |
110 212 |
34.2 65.8 |
24.11 | < 0.01 | |
Use of social media Yes No |
189 119 |
61.4 38.6 |
117 205 |
36.3 63.7 |
39.47 | < 0.01 | |
Location of residence Urban Semi-urban Village |
103 105 100 |
33.4 34.1 32.5 |
72 39 211 |
22.4 12.1 65.5 |
75.08 | < 0.01 |
In general, there were more participants in the intervention than the control group with smartphones (53.6% vs. 34.2%). There was a significant association between the ownership of smartphones and being part of the intervention program (p < 0.01). Students from the intervention group reported the highest use of social media (61.4%). By contrast, 36.3% of participants in the control group reported using social media. There was a significant association between the use of social media and being linked to the intervention program (p < 0.01).
Adolescents’ knowledge and perception related to early marriage
A majority of teenagers from both the intervention (99.7%) and control groups (89.1%) had good knowledge of early marriage, Table 2.
Table 2. Knowledge and perception of respondents related to early marriage for intervention and control groups | ||||||||
Statements | Proportion (SK) P1 |
Confidence interval 95% |
Proportion (non- SK) P2 |
Confidence interval 95% |
P1-P2 | P-value | ||
LCL | UCL | LCL | UCL | |||||
Early marriage is harmful | .996 | .990 | 1.00 | .8913 | .857 | .925 | .105 | < .01 |
Minimal legal age for boys is 21 | .980 | .965 | .995 | .8467 | .805 | .888 | .133 | < .01 |
Minimal legal age for girls is 18 | .990 | .979 | 1.00 | .9721 | .953 | .991 | .018 | < .01 |
Early marriage is a legal offense | .987 | .974 | .999 | .878 | .840 | .911 | .109 | < .01 |
There is legal punishment for early marriage | .967 | .947 | .987 | .7143 | .664 | .763 | .253 | < .01 |
Punishment for early marriage is imprisonment and fine | .957 | .935 | .980 | .4783 | .423 | .532 | .479 | < .01 |
Early marriage has implications on health | .981 | .966 | .9964 | .618 | .564 | .671 | .363 | < .01 |
Early marriage increases child mortality | .931 | .903 | .9559 | .7108 | .658 | .763 | .220 | < .01 |
Early marriage stops/limits access to education | .970 | .951 | .989 | .77 | .721 | .818 | .200 | < .01 |
The proportion of respondents who were concerned with the health implications of early marriage was 98.1% in the intervention group compared to 61.5% in the control group. About 93.1% of the respondents in the intervention group and 71.1% of the respondents in the control group answered correctly stating that early marriage increases child death rate. When asked whether early marriage prevents or restricts access to schooling, a difference of around 20% was found in the proportion of correct answers recorded in both the intervention and control group participants.
Attitude and beliefs related to early marriage
Table 3 shows the respondents’ attitudes and beliefs regarding early marriage.
Table 3. Attitude and beliefs of respondents related to early marriage by intervention and control groups | ||||||||
Statements | Proportion (SK) P1 |
Confidence Interval 95% |
Proportion (non- SK) P2 |
Confidence interval 95% |
P1-P2 | P-value | ||
LCL | UCL | LCL | UCL | |||||
Early Marriage protects a girl | .9903 | .979 | 1.00 | .832 | .791 | .873 | .158 | < .01 |
Early Marriage is good to raise family | .9903 | .979 | 1.00 | .788 | .744 | .833 | .201 | < .01 |
Mature appearance is readiness for marriage | .9156 | .884 | .946 | .677 | .625 | .728 | .238 | < .01 |
girl under 18 is more fertile than above 18 | .9643 | .943 | .985 | .720 | .671 | .769 | .243 | < .01 |
Early marriage hampers the scope of study | .9675 | .947 | .987 | .757 | .711 | .804 | .209 | < .01 |
Main role of woman is, as wife/mother | .9546 | .931 | .977 | .593 | .539 | .646 | .361 | < .01 |
Daughter's education is less important | .961 | .939 | .982 | .711 | .661 | .760 | .249 | < .01 |
Confidence to influence community decision on child marriage |
.9545 | .931 | .977 | .543 | .489 | .590 | .411 | < .01 |
A large proportion of participants (91.5%) from the intervention group disagreed with the statement that physical change signified a girl’s preparedness for marriage. Additionally, 96.4% of participants in the intervention group disagreed that girls under 18 were more fertile (capable of childbearing) than those over 18. When asked whether early marriage was a barrier to the access to education, almost all the participants (96.8%) in the intervention group and three quarters (75.8%) of the participants in the control group shared the view that early marriage hindered the future scope of education. When participants were asked to comment whether education was perceived as being important for girls, a significant proportion of participants (28.9%) in the intervention group stated that a girl’s education was not equally important in comparison to boys. On the other hand, only a small proportion of participants in the intervention group had negative attitudes indicating that girls did not deserve to be treated equally as far as education was concerned.
Early marriage practices
More than half (61.2%) of the participants in the intervention group and almost half (47.7%) of participants in the control group stated that they knew girls in their community who had been married off under the age of 18 the previous year. There was a significant association (p < 0.01) between receiving the intervention and knowing whether a girl under the age of 18 in their community was married off in the previous year.
Table 4. Early marriage among respondents by intervention and control groups | ||||||
Statements | Intervention (SK) | Control (non-SK) | χ2 | p-value | ||
n | (%) | n | (%) | |||
A girl under 18 from your area got married last year. Yes No Don't know |
188 90 29 |
61.2 29.3 9.4 |
137 80 70 |
47.7 27.9 24.4 |
24.92 |
< 0.01 |
Early marriage increased in your area last year. Yes No Don't know |
133 127 47 |
43.3 41.4 15.3 |
92 106 89 |
32.1 36.9 31.0 |
21.68 | < 0.01 |
A Boy under 21 from your area got married last year. Yes No Don't know |
70 206 31 |
22.80 67.10 10.10 |
85 121 81 |
29.6 42.2 28.2 |
45.24 |
< 0.01 |
School teachers discourage on early marriage Yes No |
288 19 |
93.8 6.2 |
198 89 |
69.0 31.0 |
61.43 |
< 0.01 |
Your parents discussed the negative effects of early marriage. Yes No |
229 78 |
74.6 25.4 |
90 197 |
31.4 68.6 |
111.51 |
< 0.01 |
Peer education changed the perception of early marriage of your parents. Yes No Don't know |
280 8 19 |
91.2 2.6 6.2 |
177 26 84 |
61.7 9.1 29.3 |
73.173 |
< 0.01 |
Peer education changed the perception of neighbors about early marriage. Yes No |
300 7 |
97.7 2.3 |
214 73 |
74.6 25.4 |
68.24 |
< 0.01 |
Heard of or read about “reduce early marriage” last year in Bangladesh Yes No Don't know |
265 24 18 |
86.3 7.8 5.9 |
145 83 59 |
50.5 28.9 20.6 |
88.91 | < 0.01 |
Try to stop any early marriage in your area Yes No |
131 176 |
42.7 57.3 |
103 184 |
35.9 64.1 |
2.85 | .09 |
Respondents from the intervention group showed a negative attitude towards child marriage. A range of prevailing ideas of child marriage on traditional grounds was found in this study. For example, compared to the control group, more adolescents in the control intervention group rejected the idea that women’s suitability for marriage starts with their puberty. Furthermore, a larger proportion of adolescents in the intervention group acknowledged that child marriage was a barrier to better health and education. A similar pattern of results was obtained in the study by Ferdousi et al. (2013). They found that parents and relatives helped teenage girls get married in conformity with local social norms before they reach full adulthood in terms of both physical and mental development. A similar pattern of results was obtained in a previous study conducted in Bangladesh, where the authors found that the participants of the intervention group experienced lower risk of child marriage relative to the
control group (Amin, Saha & Ahmed, 2018). Understanding prevailing social norms which impact early marriage decisions is crucial to designing and enforcing interventions that promote health and well-being of adolescent girls. The results supported the claim that increasing public awareness by involving students, parents, and local stakeholders reduces early marriage at a significant rate. For example, Better Life Options – a school-based intervention program in India became successful in changing perceptions and influencing adolescent girls’ attitudes towards early marriage. The outcome of the intervention reveals that the participation of the school girls in negotiating marriage decisions increased in the group under intervention (Temin & Heck, 2020).
Many respondents from the control group lacked knowledge of the fundamental aspects of child marriage. For instance, 16.3% of adolescents in the Control group expressed that they did not know the legal age of marriage for boys and girls. On the other hand, the intervention that SK carried out in the same age range and in the same regions generated a difference of 98% through effectively circulating this information among teenage males and girls. In order to raise awareness among adolescents, SK groups have been crucial in disseminating information for the prevention of early marriage.
In addition to information on legal matters, the Control group possessed a low level of understanding regarding reproductive health issues. A large number of participants (38.4%) from the Control group were unaware of the dangers associated with adolescent pregnancy posing adverse health consequences to mothers and to their unborn children. The proportion of respondents disagreeing with the idea that women should not wait long before they become wives and mothers was higher in the intervention. Besides, respondents from the Control group had a very limited understanding of maternal and child mortality in Bangladesh compared to respondents in the intervention group. Teenage girls in the intervention group were more conscious of their own bodies and health due to the program’s effect. Weekly conversations and activities run by SK clubs might have increased knowledge among adolescents. Moreover, supervision and help provided by teachers and master trainers made them capable of disseminating information about early marriage and reproductive health-related issues. This result was in line with a previous study conducted in Uttar Pradesh of India where the author’s analysis of the impact of school-based intervention suggested significant differences in overall knowledge about reproductive health among students (Acharya, 2009). The lack of knowledge about sex education and adverse consequences of reproductive health was significantly associated with girls’ increased risk for early marriage. This indicated that better knowledge about the consequences of early marriage and reproductive health complications was more among the subjects exposed to community mobilization.
The teenagers in the intervention group were aware of the legal age of marriage. They were also aware of the number of teenage girls in their area who are married off before their legal age. More than half of the adolescents from the intervention group stated that they knew boys and girls were married off in their area before their legal age of marriage. Comparisons revealed that the differences were high in the Control group; the participants stated that nearly half of the girls and boys married off before the legal age. A large proportion of participants from the intervention group believed that due to the information they gathered through taking part in SK club events, they might be a potent agent in the fight against child marriage. This demonstrates how effective SK is at educating, empowering, and raising awareness among the youth about the need to prevent child marriage.
There were several limitations in this study. First, this project was a part of a cross-sectional study design, which means that a relationship cannot be drawn between the outcome and cause variables. Therefore, the relationships between the variables should be considered tentative. Second, the respondents who participated in this study had to provide a range of information which required them to recollect events over a longer time interval. The control sample may not turn out to be completely comparable. Third, to some extent, the control group sample failed to satisfy the criterion of being similar to the intervention group in all respects in terms of types of educational institutions. Thus, the data from the Control group may be induced with recollection bias.
The main objective of the study was to observe the difference between adolescents engaging in SK intervention and adolescents not engaging in this intervention based on their knowledge, attitudes, and practices on child marriage. The intervention group performed significantly better regarding the level of knowledge, positive attitude and practices compared to the control group. SK’s intervention program is a potential predictor of increasing knowledge and behavior change through a peer-led and multi-level advocacy effort. Those participants who continued to engage in this intervention-induced and awareness-raising program experienced an increase in knowledge and awareness; this indicated effectiveness in changing attitudes and perception towards early marriage.
The members of SK school-based clubs had a deeper comprehension of the significance of peer education regarding the prevention of early marriage. The study provides new insights into how exposure to the school-based peer education program changes adolescents’ level of knowledge, attitudes, and practices. These results add to the knowledge regarding the effect of the peer-led program in preventing early marriage in a society where gender-inequitable norms and child marriage are widely prevalent. The program has created a platform where adolescents have been actively involved in the campaign against child marriage, raising awareness among teenagers and parents in the community about the consequences of child marriage. Teenagers became well aware of the relationships between early marriage and the devastating consequences for girls' health which is linked to school dropout. School-based peer education positively influences the knowledge and attitudes of adolescents and has a fundamental role in preventing early marriage. Additionally, the community still has to be mobilized more, and information needs to be shared with everyone, especially those who live in remote villages. The study proposes the engagement of more peers in the health education campaign who can be considered important agents of behavior change. SK's community mobilization framework demonstrated that it is a potential driver of adolescents' empowerment. The findings of this study can be utilized to evaluate the existing situation in terms of early marriage planning, programming, and policy lobbying.
AcknowledgmentsRights and permissions | |
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |